Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles for Residential Roofing

When considering a roofing material that balances cost, aesthetics, and durability, asphalt shingles often rise to the top for many homeowners. But like any choice, there are trade-offs that must be weighed carefully. Understanding the full spectrum of advantages and disadvantages is critical to making an informed decision about your home’s most essential feature. This comprehensive guide dives into the nuances of asphalt shingles to help you assess if they’re the right fit for your home.

Introduction: The Mainstay of American Roofs

The rise of asphalt shingles is a story steeped in pragmatism and functionality. Initially gaining traction in the early 20th century for its cost-effective and water-resistant properties, asphalt shingles have since become the most common roofing material used in the United States. The reasons behind their popularity are varied, but it’s a combination of their versatility, ease of installation, and reliability in moderate weather conditions that keep them on the crest of the residential roofing wave.

Pros of Asphalt Shingles

The array of benefits that asphalt shingles offer can make them a compelling choice for homeowners looking for a practical roofing solution.

Affordability: A Knockout One-Two Punch

The first benefit that often tips the scales in favor of asphalt shingles is their cost. Compared to other roofing materials such as metal or slate, asphalt shingles are significantly less expensive to purchase and install. This lower cost can make a substantial difference for homeowners on a tight budget or a home investment plan.

Style Without Compromise

While cost-effectiveness is a major draw, it’s the multitude of styles and colors that truly sets asphalt shingles apart. Whether you want the look of cedar shake, slate, or the traditional three-tab shingle, asphalt can mimic the appearance of more expensive materials, giving you the aesthetics you crave at a price that doesn’t break the bank.

Builders Love It for a Reason

Ease of installation is another significant advantage. For construction and renovation specialists, working with asphalt shingles is straightforward, and their familiarity with the material can reduce labor costs and time. Additionally, once installed, the maintenance is minimal, ensuring peace of mind for the homeowner.

Moderate Climate’s Best Friend

In regions with mild or moderate climates, asphalt shingles can offer a long-lasting solution. They hold up admirably against the vagaries of mild temperature changes and infrequent severe weather, making them a practical choice for many residential environments.

Cons of Asphalt Shingles

Despite the list of positives, there are caveats to consider before committing to asphalt shingles for your roofing needs.

The Limitation of Lifespans

Compared to other roofing materials, the lifespan of asphalt shingles leaves something to be desired. While modern shingles are more durable than their predecessors, they typically last around 15 to 30 years, and this is highly contingent on various factors, such as weather, maintenance, and the quality of the shingles.

Battling the Storms

Extreme weather can be the downfall of asphalt shingles. High winds, hail, and rapidly changing temperatures can cause shingles to lift, break, or lose their sealing, leading to leaks and the need for premature replacement or repair.

The Green Cost of Asphalt

The environmental implications of asphalt shingles are a point of concern. The production, use, and disposal of asphalt shingles—notably the petroleum usage in their production—have led to discussions about their carbon footprint and long-term sustainability.

The Mossy Mystery

In damp and shaded areas, asphalt shingles are susceptible to algae and mold growth. While not always damaging, the presence of these organisms may present a cosmetic issue and require additional maintenance.

Comparison with Other Roofing Materials

To provide a more comprehensive viewpoint, it’s essential to contrast asphalt shingles with alternative roofing materials to see how they stack up.

Metal: The New Sheriff in Town

Metal roofing has gained popularity due to its longevity and environmental impact. Although more expensive upfront, metal roofs can last 50 years or more, are highly recyclable, and are increasingly being considered a more energy-efficient option.

Tile and Wood: The Classically Expensive

Tiles and wood shingles offer a unique aesthetic that is particularly attractive to certain homeowners. However, their high cost, weight, and specific installation requirements can limit their appeal and practicality for the average household.

Considerations for Homeowners

Making a roofing decision that is right for your home and your budget involves considering various factors that go beyond the material itself.

The Budget Bearer

The cost of asphalt shingles is not just limited to the initial installation. Homeowners should factor in long-term maintenance and possible earlier replacement when assessing the true financial implications. Additionally, considering the duration of your stay in the home can help in gauging the return on your investment.

Nature’s Fury

If you live in an area prone to severe weather, the potential for high repair or replacement costs may outweigh the initial lower installation expenses. Understanding your region’s climate patterns and the resilience of your roofing material is crucial in making a choice that ensures your home’s protection.

Sustaining Sustainability

For the Eco-conscious homeowner, the environmentally-friendly profile of asphalt shingles is a point of contention. Considering the lifecycle impact of your roofing material and exploring alternative green options can help align your home improvement choices with your environmental values.

Maintenance Tips for Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Regular maintenance can extend the life of your asphalt shingle roof and help you get the most out of your investment. From cleaning to inspection, here are some tips to keep your roof in top condition.

The Clean and the Inspect

Cleaning your roof of debris and preventing the buildup of algae with a suitable cleaner can help preserve its appearance and material integrity. Periodic inspections for loose or damaged shingles are also crucial and can be easily done with a pair of binoculars from the ground.

The Repair Prompt

If you notice any issues during your inspection, it’s vital to address them promptly. Small repairs today can mitigate more considerable expenditure down the road.


While asphalt shingles continue to be a popular choice for many homeowners, making the right decision about your residential roofing requires a thoughtful evaluation of both the benefits and drawbacks. Understanding the context in which asphalt shingles operate, including cost, climate, and personal preferences, will ensure that the roof over your head not only looks good but also provides the protection and peace of mind you deserve. Assessing the longevity, performance under different weather conditions, and environmental impact will further guide you towards an informed decision that suits your home and your values.

Arming yourself with knowledge is the first step towards making a decision you’ll be content with for years to come. And when it comes to your roofing, contentment should be accompanied by confidence in the strength and reliability of your shelter. Whether it’s the classic asphalt shingle, a more contemporary metal roof, or another material that wins your favor, may your choice bring you comfort and your household security.

Author: Fred Matzkei

Fred Matzkei is a seasoned professional in the roofing industry with over two decades of hands-on experience. Driven by a passion for educating homeowners and industry professionals alike, Fred has become a prolific writer and publisher of roofing tips and general roofing information.

Through his contributions to the roofing community, Fred Matzkei has become an invaluable resource for anyone looking to understand roofing better, make informed decisions about their roofing needs, or simply keep up with the latest developments in the field.

Learn More